Hattox, Ralph S. Coffee and Coffeehouses: The Origins of a Social Beverage in the Medieval Near East. Seattle and London: University of Washington Press. Coffee and Coffeehouses has 70 ratings and 11 reviews. J.M. said: Not so much a history of coffee and its public institutions, as a look at how something. Coffee and Coffeehouses: The Origins of a Social Beverage in the Medieval Near East. Front Cover. Ralph S Hattox. University of Washington Press,

Author: Kagataxe Jujinn
Country: Poland
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: History
Published (Last): 23 August 2009
Pages: 425
PDF File Size: 4.42 Mb
ePub File Size: 14.11 Mb
ISBN: 226-8-92900-967-9
Downloads: 67854
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Grozil

Project MUSE – Coffee and Coffeehouses

The second point to cofee made about these early prohibi- tions is that, far from starting off as an issue solely of inter- est to the religiously inclined who sought to express their alarm over this new habit, it was, from the first, a matter with which the civil authorities were very much concerned.

To the Yemenis, of course, it was vital, and cofee took steps though ones that were, in the long run, futile to preserve their monopoly.

On the negative side, we become instantly aware that what seems important to us, what we wish to study in minute detail, is in reality but a rather insignificant incident in the history of things as a whole, at least history as contemporary chroniclers perceived it.

A group, pro- voked by the strength of coffeehousse sermons, set out according to JazIrT, on their own, a coffeenouses mob of rowdies without official sanction and attacked several coffeehouses, smashed the fixtures, and beat many of those they found there.

Coffee and Coffeehouses / Ralph S. Hattox

Muhammad ibn Mahmud al-Zaynl al-Husaynl, the six- teenth-century author of a short untitled treatise attacking coffee, similarly touches on the theme of the physical harm that can come from coffee drinking. Far better to start by selling the already brewed beverage from little stands or shops, in order to build up a demand. Jazlri ckffeehouses an additional objection to the official ver- sion that deserves some consideration. Hattox, Coffee and Coffeehouses: Near Eastern studies, University of Washington: The state may choose to act upon it, of course.

Coffee and Coffeehouses

A laughable notion these days to be sure since the folks ocffee see populating Starbucks will hardly vaunt and venge against starched white privilege, but back then it was an actual social worry!


There seems to have been the attempt, especially ciffeehouses Syria and Iraq, to create a park or gardenlike atmosphere, to sur- round the patron with refreshing sights and sounds unlike those of either the city or the desert: This innovation is often attributed to the scholar and Sufi, Muhammad al- DhabhanT, who died circa The advocates of coffee not only made no effort to hide this fact, but they quite openly put it forward as one of the best reasons to drink coffee.

We thus see three distinct types of coffee outlet emerge early on, which for want of better terms we can label as the coffee stall, the coffee shop, and the coffeehouse. Built on the Johns Hopkins University Campus. These were de- velopments, however, of the years after the debate had The Great Coffee Controversy 9 died down.

Their little assembly itself was actually quite primitive, tame and of little interest. Among the more prominent of these was insomnia saharwhich is the natural extension of the beneficial property of giving vigor for work at night. For Turkish words, wherever possible, I prefer to use modern Turkish orthog- raphy, although at times I include extra diacritical marks to indicate the original spelling.

Full text of “Coffee And Coffeehouses”

As a general rule, we can say that: And perhaps more important, the social context. Sign In Forgot password? Thus, yellow bile is considered as corresponding to dryness and heat, black bile to dryness and cold, phlegm to moistness and cold, and blood to moistness and heat.

Stories of this sort have appeared in the sections on beverages in in- numerable cookbooks, the authors coffehouses adding their own embarrassingly offensive explanations for this seemingly petty and irrational behavior over a trifling matter.

Those who gave medical arguments for prohibiting coffee were foffeehouses challenged by others who could produce physi- cians of eminence to testify that it had positive curative properties.

As we shall see, the four distinct but mutually tolerant Sunni schools of jurisprudence madhhabpi. Hattox explains the history of coffee in consideration of not only historic background but also specific Cooffee sources.

When asked for their opinion concerning coffee and the meetings held for the consumption of it, the ju- rists chose to deal with the meetings first. Consumption of any amount of these beverages leaves the offender open to the prescribed corporal punishment, either forty or eighty stripes.


The immediate temptation, when faced with a series of coincidental reports such as this, is to assume, espe- hatto in the case of the three ShadhilTs, that the sources have confused one for the other.

Most, even the largest, consisted of one large main room, which served both as kitchen and salon for the pa- trons.

While in certain fields — penal law, for example — there coffeehousees considerable gaps in the legal system, in other areas 46 Wine, Coffee, and covfee Holy Law 47 the centuries of commentaries, extrapolations, and codifi- cations have served to clarify the religious and moral pre- cepts originally given the believers through Muhammad, and to broaden in some respects and limit in others the interpretation of these principles.

Kopi dijadikan sebab orang mula bicara tentang politik, tentang kebebasan, seni, kebahagiaan dan paling akhir ialah tentang tuhan. We benefit, then, indirectly from the fact that in order for us to understand the reasons for the legal wrangling, we are taken back to the origins of coffee drinking and the growing popularization of the coffeehouse culture. Coffee was demonstrably not intoxicating by the standards of the sharp a.

These gen- erally fall into two categories determined by size and clien- tele: Had they merely dumped sacks of coffee in the marketplaces of the larger cities, demand would prob- ably have been very sluggish indeed. To pursue such questions, it is first necessary to realize that in attributing motives to the actions of the protag- onists we must discern three distinct levels of interpreta- tion: What we are left with for the earli- est period, then, are historical table-scraps, a page here, a sentence there, from which we must piece together much of our discussion and chronology.